Over the years many well-known, and collectible, authors made their first print appearances in magazines. Agatha Christie, Edgar Allen Poe, Jack London, and Edgar Rice Burroughs are just a few examples.
In some cases a magazine was the only place a story ever appeared. In others, a story appeared in a magazine months, or even years, before it was published as a book. Because of their length, many of the stories were serialized over several issues of a magazine. Whether the stories eventually appeared in book format or not, the magazine issues that contained these stories have become highly collectible.
This featured post looks at Edgar Rice Burroughs whose work appeared in numerous magazines over a period of several years making the magazine’s issues with his stories in them highly sought after by collectors today.
Edgar Rice Burroughs is best known as the creator of Tarzan but many of his magazine stories centered around other characters/subjects and the inclusion of anything he wrote dramatically increases the value of that issue of a magazine over regular issues.
Before we look at specific magazines, there are a few generalizations we should mention.
First, most of the magazines on this list were published in the early nineteen hundreds and are not going to be found at garage sales similar to those we’ve talked about to this point. The places to look for these are antique shops, antique malls, flea markets, estate sales, and auction sales.
Second, much of Burroughs’ work appeared in magazines that, by themselves, are often not well known and have little collector following. This means that unless a dealer is aware a particular issue contains a Burroughs story, when found, they can often be purchased for $20 or less – often for much less.
Third, when a story was serialized the issue of the magazine containing the first installment often had cover art relating to the story. This means that issues containing the first installment of a Tarzan story often had Tarzan on the front cover. Since the covers are a dead give-away to what’s inside, you will often find these issues priced much higher than the issues containing the other installments of the story.
Any issue with cover art pertaining to any of Burroughs’ stories increases the value of the magazine, but be careful you don’t overpay when buying issues with cover art.
While I can’t promise the following list of magazines is complete, it does include the majority of magazines the Burroughs’ stories appeared in.
All Around Magazine
“Beyond Thirty” – serialized in issues between 12/1915 – 3/1917
Normal issues can be found for $10 to $20. Issues with Burroughs stories should bring $100 or more on eBay.
The All Story Magazine
“Under The Moons Of Mars” – serialized in issues between 2/1912 – 7/1912
“”Tarzan Of The Apes” – 10/1912
“The Gods Of Mars” – serialized in issues between 1/1913 – 5/1913
“The Cave Girl” – serialized in issues between 7/1913 – 9/1913
“A Man Without A Soul” – 11/1913
“The Warlords Of Mars” – serialized in issues 12/1913 – 3/1914
The All Story Weekly (same magazine but the name changes)
“The Eternal Lover” – 3/7/1914
“The Mad King” – 3/21/1914
“At The Earth’s Core” – serialized in issues 4/4/1914 – 4/25/1914
All-Story Cavalier Weekly (same magazine but name changes again)
“The Mucker” – serialized in issues 10/24/1914 – 11/14/1914
“The Beasts Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues 5/16/1914 – 6/13/1914
“Sweetheart Primeval” – serialized in issues 1/23/1915 – 2/13/1915
The All Story Weekly (once again, same magazine but another name change)
“Pellucidar” – 5/29/1915
“Barney Custer Of Beatrice” – serialized in issues 8/7/1915 – 8/21/1915
“The Son Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues 12/4/1915 – 1/8/1916
“Thuvia Maid Of Mars” – serialized in issues 4/8/1916 – 4/22/1916
“The Return Of The Mucker” – serialized in issues 6/17/1916 – 7/15/1916
“The Girl From Farris’s” – serialized in issues 9/23/1916 – 10/14/1916
“Tarzan And The Jewels Of Opar” – serialized in issues 11/18/1916 – 12/16/1916
“The Caveman” – serialized in issues 3/31/1917 – 4/21/1917
“The Lad And The Lion” – serialized in issues 6/30/1917 – 7/14/1917
“H.R.H. The Rider” – serialized in issues 12/14/1918 – 12/28/1918
“Tarzan The Untamed” – serialized in issues 3/20/1920 – 4/17/1920 (Only the last part of this story appeared in All Story Weekly. The first six installments were published in the 3/1919 to 8/1919 issues of Red Book magazine.)
Nearly any issue of the above magazine in reasonable condition should bring between $75 and $150 on eBay. Issues containing “Under The Moons Of Mars” may approach four figures. The 10/1912 issue containing “Tarzan Of The Apes” has the potential of getting into the low five figure range.
Amazing Stories Magazine
“John Carter And The Giant Of Mars” – 1/1941
“The City Of Mummies” – 3/1941
“Black Pirates Of Barsoom” – 6/1941
“Yellow Men Of Mars” – 8/1941
“Invisible Men Of Mars” – 10/1941
“The Return To Pellucidar” – 2/1942
“Men Of The Bronze Age” – 3/1942
“Tiger Girl” – 4/1942
“Skeleton Men Of Jupiter” – 2/1943
“Savage Pellucidar” – 11/1943
Most Amazing Stories magazines from this time period can be purchased for $5 to $10. Issues with Burroughs stores will bring prices between $20 and $50 on eBay.
NOTE: In the 1960’s Amazing Stories published three Tarzan stories. These later issues don’t have a huge premium over regular prices but are provided here in an attempt to be complete.
“John Carter And The Giants Of Mars” – 4/1961
“Savage Pellucidar” – 11/1963
“Skeleton Men Of Jupiter” – 1/1964
Amazing Stories Annual
“Mastermind Of Mars” – 1927
This was the only issue of this magazine ever published and it regularly sells for prices in the $200+ range. This price is driven by the Burroughs story it contains so there’s not as much of a chance of picking it up at a bargain price.
Argosy All Story Weekly Magazine
“Tarzan The Terrible” – serialized in issues between 2/12/1921 – 3/26/1921
“The Efficiency Expert” – serialized in issues between 10/08/1921 – 10/29/1921
“The Chessmen Of Mars” – serialized in issues between 2/18/1922 – 4/1/1922
“Tarzan And The Golden Lion” – serialized in issues between 12/09/1922 – 4/1/1923
“The Moon Maid” – serialized in issues between 5/05/1923 – 6/02/1923
“Tarzan And The Ant Men” – serialized in issues between 2/02/1924 – 3/15/1924
“The Bandit Of Hell’s Bend” – serialized in issues between 9/13/1924 – 10/18/1924
‘The Moon Men” – serialized in issues between 2/21/1925 – 2/28/1925
“The Red Hawk” – serialized in issues between 9/05/1925 – 9/19/1925
“The War Chief” – serialized in issues between 4/16/1927 – 5/14/1927
“Apache Devil” – serialized in issues between 5/19/1928 – 6/23/1928
“Tarzan And The City Of Gold” – serialized in issues between 3/12/1932 – 4/16/1932
“The Pirates Of Venus” – serialized in issues between 9/17/1932 – 10/22/1932
“Lost On Venus” – serialized in issues between 3/04/1933 – 4/18/1933
“Tarzan And The Magic Men” – serialized in issues between 9/19/1936 – 10/03/1936
“Seven Worlds To Conquer” – serialized in issues between 1/09/1937 – 2/13/1937
“The Resurrection Of Jimber-Jaw” – 2/20/1937
“Carson Of Venus” – serialized in issues between 1/08/1938 – 2/12/1938
“The Red Star Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues between 3/19/1938 – 4/23/1938
“The Synthetic Men Of Mars” – serialized in issues between 1/07/1939 – 2/11/1939
“The Quest Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues between 8/23/1941 – 9/06/1941
When found, regular issues can often be purchased for $5 to $20 each. Issues containing stories by Burroughs prior to 1935 should bring $100 or more on eBay. Issues later than 1936 will bring at least $40 to $50 and often more.
Best Stories Magazine
“Tarzan Of The Apes” – Serialized in issues between 8/1926 – 4/1927
Regular issues can be found for $10 - $15. The eight issues with this story in them should bring $50 or more on eBay.
Blue Book Magazine
“The New Stories Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues between 9/1916 – 8/1917
“The Oakdale Affair” – 3/1918
“The Land That Time Forgot” – 8/1918
“The People That Time Forgot” – 10/1918
“Out Of Time’s Abyss” – 12/1918
“Tarzan, Lord Of The Jungle” – serialized in issues between 12/1927 – 5/1928
“Tarzan And The Last Empire” – serialized in issues between 10/1928 – 2/1929
“Tanar Of Pellucidar” – serialized in issues between 3/1929 – 8/1929
“Tarzan At The Earth’s Core” – serialized in issues between 9/1929 – 3/1930
“A Fighting Man Of Mars” – serialized in issues between 4/1930 – 9/1930
“Tarzan, Guard Of The Jungle” – serialized in issues between 10/1930 – 4/1931
“The Land Of Hidden Men” – serialized in issues between 5/1931 – 9/1931
“The Triumph Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues between 10/1931 – 3/1932
“Tarzan And The Leopard Men” – serialized in issues between 8/1932 – 1/1933
“Swords Of Mars” – serialized in issues between 11/1934 – 4/1935
“Tarzan And The Immortal Men” – serialized in issues between 10/1935 – 3/1936
“Tarzan And The Elephant Men” – serialized in issues between 11/1937 – 1/1938
“Tarzan And The Champion” – 4/1940
“Beyond The Farthest Star” – 1/1942
These are some of the least expensive magazines containing Burroughs’ material. While the issues prior to 1920 will normally bring $75 or more, those after that year often sell for only $20 to $50 on eBay.
Fantastic Adventures Magazine
“The Scientists Revolt” – 7/1939
“Slaves Of The Fish Men” – 3/1941
“Goddess Of Fire” – 7/1941
“The Living Dead” – 11/1941
“War On Venus” – 3/1942
This is another magazine where the price difference between normal issues and issues containing Burroughs stories isn’t that great. Normal issues sell $15 to $25 and issues with stories by Burroughs bring around $50 or a little more.
Idle Hour Magazine
“The Eternal Lover” – serialized in issues between 11/1915 – 12/1915
Can be found for $10 to $20 or less. These two issues should bring $75+ apiece on eBay.
Liberty Magazine
“Tarzan And The Lion Men” – serialized in issues between 11/1933 –1/1934
Regular issues are available for $5 to $15 each. The Burroughs issues will bring $50 to $125 on eBay.
NOTE: The 9/30/1939 issue of Liberty Magazine contained an early article about Alcoholics Anonymous and regularly sells for $150 to as much as $300, so if you ever come across it be sure and pick it up.
Modern Mechanics And Invention
“Conquest Of The Moon” – serialized in issues between 11/1928 – 2/1929
“Lost Inside The Earth” – serialized in issues between 2/1929 – 4/1929
“Carter Of The Red Planet” – serialized in issues between 4/1929 – 7/1929
Regular issues of this magazine can often be purchased for $10 - $20. Issues with Burroughs stories in them should bring $50 - $75 on eBay.
Munsey’s Magazine
“The Girl From Hollywood” – serialized in issues between 6/1922 – 11/1922
Issues normally sell for $10 to $20. The ones with this story in them should bring $50 to $100 on eBay.
New Story
“The Return Of Tarzan” – serialized in issues between 6/1913 – 12/1913
“The Outlaw Of Torn” – serialized in issues between 1/1914 – 11/1914
Most issues are worth $10 to $20. Issues with Burroughs stories should bring $150 or more on eBay.
Red Book Magazine
“Tarzan The Untamed – serialized in issues between 3/1919 – 8/1919 (Only the first six installments of this story appeared in Red Book. The remainder of the story was serialized in The All Story Weekly Magazine).
Most issues are worth $20 to $30. Issues with Burroughs stories should bring $125 or more on eBay.
Thrilling Adventure Stories
“The Terrible Tenderfoot” – serialized in issues between 3/1940 – 5/1940
“Tarzan And The Jungle Murders” – 6/1940
When found in antique shops normal issues often bring $25 -$35. The Terrible Tenderfoot issues should bring $40 to $75 per issue on eBay. The Tarzan issue should bring $60 to $100.
Triple X Magazine
“Tarzan Returns” – serialized in issues between 11/1929 – 2/1930
Regular issues of this magazine are usually found for $20 - $30 and the Burroughs story issues sell for between $30 and $50, so there’s not a lot of room for profit here unless you get them really cheap.
Photo by Ivan Fourie
Popularity: 56% [?]